Share this story Share on Facebook icon Share on Twitter icon Share on Pinterest icon Share on Google Plus icon Share on Linked In icon Share via Email icon

How new novelists can deal with criticism from editors


Criticism, especially for debut novelists, is hard to take. Unlike non-fiction, novels and short stories tend to be personal creations, often based on the writer’s experiences; unsurprisingly, any criticism aimed at them can feel like a personal attack.

But criticism from editors is often meant to be constructive; the editor is trying to help the author improve her or his writing. However, not all criticism is worth paying attention to.

When is criticism from editors helpful?

Criticism from editors is helpful when the editor’s suggestions: improve the flow of the writing; clear up inconsistencies in plots and characters; fix timelines that don’t make sense; add depth to the characters and the relationships between them. It’s also wise to consider similar comments from more than one editor.

When is criticism from editors less than helpful?

In some cases, criticism from editors is subjective; in other words, your book doesn’t fit the editor’s personal taste. This type of feedback might not be worth taking to heart. Examples of subjective criticism include the following: the editor doesn’t like or understand your main characters; the editor makes vague comments (e.g., “I’m not feeling it”); you hired a freelance substantive and/or line editor to pre-edit your manuscript, and the editor doesn’t agree with the freelance editor’s ideas and choices.

The bottom line

Any changes you make to your book that are based on an editor’s feedback should improve it. Following the wrong advice, especially from an editor who doesn’t “get” or “like” your book could end up hurting your book. It pays to know the difference.

By Kathleen Jones, The Quirky Novelist, read more online and follow her on Twitter


Photo credit: just.Luc, “Stricken with Self-doubt” via photopin (license)

Back to "Creative Writing" Category

11/04/2018 Share this story   Share on Facebook icon Share on Twitter icon Share on Pinterest icon Share on Google Plus icon Share on Linked In icon Share via Email icon

Recent Updates

Coffee break exercise: Libraries

Libraries are a writer's natural habitat - and the prompt for this week's creative writing exercise! ...

Read more, write better! Writing Magazine bonus content, February 2019

Background reading, exclusive audio extracts and more to complement your latest Writing Magazine ...

Under the Microscope extra: Only a Weekend

Read our suggested rewrite of a reader's novel opening ...

How to be more creative: These tips won't fail you

Turn on your creativity with our top tips for finding fresh inspiration ...

Other Articles

Coffee break exercise: Resolutions

Give your writing year a solid start by setting out your intentions in your first creative writing exercise ...

Coffee break exercise: Shops

With everyone frantically rushing round doing Christmas shopping, shops are the inspiration for this week's ...

How to be a nature writer

Dialogue Books publisher Sharmaine Lovegrove shares her inspiration and advice on nature writing ...

Coffee break exercise: Camera

Picture this – a new piece of writing that starts with a camera prompt in this week's creative writing ...